Showing posts with label Debt Equity Ratio. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Debt Equity Ratio. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

TDS ON REMUNERATION PAID TO DIRECTORS



Finance minister in budget 2012 deepened the worry lines of the directors of innumerable companies who were enjoying the remuneration from company without deduction of tax at source by inserting a new clause 1(ba) in Section 194J which expand TDS net to on any remuneration paid to Directors of a company. This clause will be effective from 1st July, 2012.
In accordance with newly inserted clause 1(ba) in Section 194J, TDS @ 10% is to be deducted from any remuneration paid to Directors of accompany with effect from 1st July, 2012. This clause reads as follows
“Any remuneration or fees or commission by whatever name called, other than those on which tax is deductible under section 192, to a director of a company shall liable to be deducted @10%.”
This decision of finance ministry was the result of bundle of uncertainties hovering over the deduction of tax at source on sitting fees, commission and remuneration paid to the directors. Sitting fees is the fees which are given to the directors for attending the meeting of board or any committee as the case may be. But now with the introduction of the above new clause (1)(ba) in section 194J, it is clear that TDS on any remuneration other than covered under salary or fees paid to directors or sitting fees or any payment of same nature by other name shall be covered under the ambit of sec. 194J and will be subjected to TDS @10%.

For the sake of easy understanding of our readers the whole issue may be bifurcated into two parts where the payments are made to directors in two ways:
a.       By way of salary.
b.      By way of fees paid for the professional services.

a)      By way salary: The readers may notice that when payments are made in nature of salary, then provisions of sec.192 are attracted. It clearly means that under such situations directors are considered as employee of the company. Generally the executive directors are paid salary and they are not entitled to sitting fees or for other services.

b)     By way of fees paid for the professional services: It may be noticed that directors’ remuneration includes payments made to Directors for services rendered in any other capacity as per the Companies Act, 1956. To further clarify this type of payments to directors the relevant sections of companies Act, 1956 i.e. sec. 198 and 309 can be relied upon. The collective interpretation of this section reveals that remuneration paid to whole time director/ managing director include payments made on account of
·         Commission,
·         sitting fees
·         any other fees paid for rendering professional services.

From above analysis and careful reading of newly inserted clause in sec.194J it is very clear that before amendment sec.194J use to apply only on amount paid for professional and technical services but with above said insertion, the sitting fees and commission paid and any payment by whatever name are dragged into realm of Sec.194J.

On above scrutiny some confusion which may arise

1.       Whether the service tax is payable when directors are paid on account of rendering services?
The board vide Circular No. 115/09/2009- ST, dated 31-7-2009 clarified that

If Companies make payments to Managing Director/Directors whether Whole-time or Independent, referring those payments as ‘Commissions’, then such payment remitted by companies to their Managing directors or directors even though termed as commission, is not the ‘commission’ that is within the ambit of business auxiliary service. Therefore there is no question of chargeability of service tax on such amount.
The board further clarified that Managing Director or Directors being perform managerial functions and they do not any perform consultancy or advisory function. The definition of management consultant service makes it clear that what is envisaged from a consultant and where the expertise of consultant is asked for is termed as advisory service and not the actual performance of the management function. The payments made by Companies, to Directors cannot be termed as payments for providing management consultancy service.
       Therefore, it is reiterated that service-tax is not chargeable under the category ‘Management Consultancy service’ on the amount paid to Directors whether Whole-time or Independent is not chargeable to service tax under. However, service –tax is chargeable if such directors provide any advice or consultancy to the company and they separately paid for such services.

2.       Whether the commission payable to director will be covered under section 194J OR 194H?
With insertion of new clause in Finance bill 2012 in sec.194J namely clause (1)(ba), it is very clear that commission or any other sum paid by any name to the director which is not covered under section 192 will fall within the ambit of sec. 194J.

3.       Whether sec.194J will attract on payment to the foreign director also?
Foreign director will be on equal footing with the Indian directors for the sake of application of TDS provisions. Hence if foreign director is full time director in any company then he will get remuneration or salary as the case maybe after deducting tax at source under section 192. On other hand if company gets professional or other management services from its foreign director then he will be called non-executive director and any payment remitted to him will attract section 194J and TDS will be deducted thereof.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Criteria-Guidelines for IT Scrutiny for AY 2010-11-FY 2009-2010

Guidelines for selection of cases for Scrutiny During 2010-11


1.       Selection of cases for scrutiny during the financial year 2010-11 will be done primarily through CASS  this year. Manual Selection for scrutiny this year will be limited only to a few cases listed below.

2.       List of cases selected during each month in accordance with selection criteria mentioned below shall be submitted by the Assessing officers to their respective Range heads by the 15th of the following month and also displayed on the notice Board of their offices .

3.       These guidelines are meant only for the use of officers of the Income Tax Department .These are not to be disclosed even if a request is made under Right to Information Act, In view of the decision of the Central Information Commission in the case of Shri Kamal Vs Director (ITA-II), CBDT (order no CIC/AT/2007/00617 dated 21.02.2008)

Selection criteria Applicable to all return at all stations
a)      Value of International transaction as defined in 92B exceeds 15 Crore.

b)      Cases involving addition in an earlier assessment year in excess of Rs 10 lacs on a substantial and recurring question of law or fact which is confirmed in appeal or is pending before on appellate authority.

c)       Cases involving addition in an earlier assessment year on the issue of transfer pricing in excess of Rs 10 Lakh or more.

d)      Assessment in survey cases for the financial year in which survey was carried out. This criteria will not apply if all of the following conditions are fulfilled:
i.            There are no impounded books or documents.
ii.            There is no retraction of disclosure, if any, made during the survey.
iii.            Declared income, excluding any disclosure made during the survey, is not less than the declared income of the preceding year.

e)      Assessment in search & Seizure cases to be made under section 158B, 158BC, 158BD, 153A,  153C & 143(3) of the IT Act.

f)       Assessment Initiated under section 147/148 of the IT Act.

g)      Assessing officer may select any return for scrutiny after recording he reason and obtaining approval of the CCIT/DGIT. The cases under this category should be selected if, there are compelling reasons and the case is not selected through CASS. These cases should be watched by CCIT/CIT in respect of the quality of assessment.

Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Thin Capitalization Rules – "Debt to Equity to Tax can no longer be tossed"

                                                                               By CA Maneet Pal
                                                                                           9810774806
                                                       http://www.capasricha.com/





Any and every business needs some kind of finance to invest in business opportunities and get rewards out of it in form of profits. Many Foreign Companies eye India as great business opportunity for expanding its operations and increase the kitty of its ultimate Foreign/ Holding Company.  

With the decision of entering in Indian markets, Companies have to take decision on their capital structure. Companies prefer to invest/ bring money into India by way of lending loan to its Indian Counterpart, there keeping high Debt-Equity Ratio. Companies borrowing large amount of loans enjoys tax deduction on the interest paid thereby on such loans. But companies may no longer be able to enjoy this huge deduction on their taxable profit as the government is planning to implement the “Thin Capitalization Rule” to avoid such tax evasion.

Before we proceed towards the Rules, let’s just have a look at what does the term “Thin Capitalization” means. The definition hereby goes as, “when a company’s capital is made up of a much greater proportion of debt than equity, that is, its leverage or gearing is too high, it is said to be thinly capitalized”

For a company to function, it needs to first take the decision of best available financing options.
There are largely two sources of finance:
·         Issue of shares in equity; and  
·         Other is by borrowing.

The source by which the company raises its finance affects the Finances and taxation of corporate income. However, generally in practice we see companies raising finance partly by equity and partly by loans that is “debt”. Interesting part, in case of raising money is that many companies prefer to raise money through loan or debt as it is deductible from the company’s taxable profit.

Now let’s analyze the equity points, if a company’s finance has large portion of equity then the shareholders or the owners have to be rewarded from the profits of the company which is essentially NOT deductible from tax! Therefore some companies sought to raise higher proportion of their funds through loans which means rather than paying a large a sum of money to their owners and not receive any tax benefit they raise large proportion of their capital through debt (preferably from their Holding company) in which they receive tax benefit as the “interest on loan” is deductible from the taxable profits of the company.


THE FINANCE EFFECT

Suppose ABC ltd raises it capital by issue of shares and debt, the equity capital consists of Rs 10,00,000 and Rs. 16, 00,000 in the form of borrowing. The bank lends the loan at 10.5% pa. Suppose the company makes the profits of 1,00,000/- during the year, out of which it has to pay, the dividend amounting to Rs 90,000. We know that at the end of the year the company has to bears a 10.5% interest on its debt which comes out to be Rs 168,000. This favours the equity shareholders since a highly geared firm will have more surpluses to distribute amongst less number of equity shareholders. Therefore the returns will be higher as compared to a less leveraged firm since debt is a cheaper source of finance than equity.
If shareholders have a nominal proportion of capital in comparison to the total finance, then the company has lower financial reserves and lenders bear the risk of solvency of company as it’s the company which has to eventually pay off large amounts of its capital (debt) with interest. There are large risks involved of failure of company to pay off the interest and debt that may lead it to declare insolvency. This will adversely impact the economy growth and reputation of company in markets.


THE TAXATION EFFECT

Taking the same illustration into consideration as mentioned above we can now deduce the tax effect as well. The real benefit of the company can be seen while analyzing the tax effect, since the company has raised more of its capital through debt the interest on raising such debt can be availed as a deduction from the company’s taxable profit. Whereas if the company had raised capital through equity the dividend paid couldn’t have been used as an expenditure that’ll give the benefit of deduction from tax.

Generally the companies, who prefer to maintain high Debt to Equity ratio, borrow funds from their foreign holding company, so as to dilute the overall negative effect of financial imbalance and gain the benefits of taxation convention.


Now where is the problem in all of this for tax and economic regularities?
There are two major problems, when a company’s capital is made up of higher proportion of debt than equity:
·         Credit Risk
·         Taxability

Credit Risk
Now in all of the above discussed work wherein companies raising a greater part of its capital through “debt” and claiming deduction on “interest on loan” All this would mean that the company has low financial reserves to meet its needs. Since most part of the finance of the company comes through debt it means that the company would have to repay it unlike equity.

Taxability
Many companies would use this higher debt as a tax saving mechanism since dividend is not deductible from the taxable profit and on the contrary interest on borrowed capital is, therefore this phenomenon may be used in saving tax.

Many foreign countries like USA, Netherlands, China, Poland, Russia have introduced this rule to put a grip on the gearing ratio. In India also, the government is planning to introduce “Thin Capitalization Rules” to dodge such tax evasions and believe to have introduced the rules in Direct Tax Code (DTC).

It would be exciting to see how and what measures does government bring in to evaluate and identify high leveraged firms. Some of the ways in which High leveraged firm can be identified are:
·         Debt to Equity Ratio
·         Subjective approach
·         Hidden profit distributions

Debt to equity ratio
Debt equity ratio = total liabilities/shareholders equity
In this approach if the company’s portion of debt exceeds by a fixed amount specified the interest on loan on the excess of the loan will be disallowed from the deduction of taxable profit.

Subjective approach
The basis on which the principle which works here is to analyze the terms and nature of the contribution of debt and the circumstances under which the financing has been made and decide whether the real nature of funds is debt or equity.

Hidden Profit Distributions
The very basic idea here is to if the loan amount exceeds an arm’s length situation that is “that the both parties in the deal are acting in their own self interest and not subject to any pressure from other party” the lender here must be considered to have an interest in the profitability of the enterprise and the loan, or any amount in excess of the arm’s-length amount, must be seen as being designed to procure share in the profits.

In conclusion we could say that it will be a big change in India if Thin Capitalization Rule gets implemented. The companies will now need to vitally review their debt to equity as the time for implementation comes closer. However the big hurdle still needs to be solved as to what ratio of debt to equity would be agreeable and what amount precisely would be feasible for tax deduction.